Subway Secret Menu & Pizza Sub Prices 2026

Pizza Sub — Every Format

Pizza Sub is a real, officially orderable Subway item — pepperoni, marinara sauce and melted cheese on toasted bread — sold in five formats at the stores we checked. The sandwich version ran $5.39–$9.59 (6″ or Footlong), the Protein Bowl and Wrap versions ran $8.79–$9.59, and the Salad version ran $7.39–$8.19. Subway’s own Personal Cheese Pizza — a separate, smaller round pizza — ran $5.69–$6.59.

Pizza Sub was not offered in any format at our Orlando restaurant when checked — a real store-to-store menu gap, the same one flagged on our Sandwiches, Protein Bowls, Wraps and Salads pages, not a data error here. These Subway Pizza Sub prices are the exact numbers we observed at checkout at Fort Worth and Columbus, not a national average.

Unofficial Secret Menu Hacks

Subway has no official published secret menu. The builds below are popular customer-invented combinations of real, regularly priced Subway ingredients — not Subway menu items, not guaranteed to be honored the same way at every location, and not separately priced. You’d simply order the real ingredients listed and pay whatever those ingredients cost on the regular menu (see our complete Subway Menu Prices guide for those prices).

• Tuna Melt — a Tuna sandwich with extra cheese, toasted.
• Chicken Cordon Bleu — roasted chicken, ham, Swiss cheese, bacon and honey mustard.
• Chicken Parmesan — roasted chicken, marinara sauce, parmesan and mozzarella.
• Spicy Nacho Steak — steak, chipotle Southwest sauce, Monterey cheddar, onions and peppers, toasted, with a bag of Nacho Cheese Doritos® added inside.
• Old Cut — a regular sandwich with the bread cut the older “V” way instead of the current straight cut.

These names and combinations come from customer roundups and social media, not from Subway itself — we’re reporting them honestly as unofficial and community-sourced, the same way we treat every unverified claim on this site.

Frequently Asked Questions